An entire screen was jam-packed as cinephiles strived to bag a seat for MAMI Mumbai Film Festival 2023’s first masterclass that saw Mani Ratnam in conversation with Imtiaz Ali. It was a heart-toheart chat with some savage one-liners from Ratnam. Excerpts from the conversation:

Talking about Dil Se, he said, “Dil Se was made around India’s 50 years of Independence. It was a reminder that not all corners of the country are liberated as one would like to believe. Shah Rukh Khan’s character was not just an All India Radio reporter, he was everyone’s voice.”

Ratnam made Raavan (2010) in two languages at a time, not many attempted to do so. The director, however, admitted that it wasn’t the right decision. “Making Raavan as a bilingual film was a mistake. It was a burden because I was literally making two films at a time, and neither the Hindi nor the Tamil audience could completely relate to it. It was a case of neither here nor there,” he said.

Elaborating on filmmakers’ constant hunt for great stories and subjects, Ratnam explains, “As a storyteller, you realise that you’re a scavenger. Even when tragedy strikes, you’re looking for stories and opportunities. I remember witnessing a blast from a close distance, and the first thing that struck me wasn’t the tragedy alone but even the technique. In films, we show that blasts generally happen from a distance, but that isn’t the case.”

The director, known for his unique vision and extracting the best out of his actors, had an interesting take on teamwork. He revealed, “I don’t want obedience from my actors, I expect contribution. I can always tell you what I want, but what more can you bring to the table? I like actors who give you that little more.” When asked what happens in case of a massive difference of opinion, Ratnam teased, “Then I tell them who’s the boss (laughs)!” Citing examples, he said, “Shah Rukh Khan and Rajinikanth often joked about this. They would say, ‘We can tell you what we feel, but you won’t accept it. This is your film, isn’t it?’”

Despite having made acclaimed films, the director feels that there is still an element of self-doubt. He revealed, “Sometimes I wonder if I am a one-trick pony. I always thought of myself as a fraud director. When I did my first film, I didn’t know how to shoot. I had to pretend that I knew. I remember Kamal Haasan telling me this when I pitched my first film to him. He said, ‘Don’t aim at the heart, aim at the gut and you will make it.’ Haasan suggested that I need to make something that a lot of people can identify with, and how you communicate with the audience is important.”

Ratnam says, “My assistant directors don’t hesitate to tell me if something doesn’t thrill them. The day they find mistakes in my work, I know they are potential filmmakers. I used to criticise films when I didn’t even know how to make one. Finding fault is important. As an audience, I am evolved. As a filmmaker, I am not! There is nothing in this art form that can be called perfect. I don’t watch my films after they are released. I can’t take it. I only see the errors and I cringe.”