Mr X is not a copy of Hollow Man-Vikram Bhatt
8:55 AM
Posted by Fenil Seta
The Bhatts, Mahesh and Vikram, shrug off inspired similarities, insist they are revisiting Nanabhai Bhatt's film by the same name from the '50s
Ankur Pathak (MUMBAI MIRROR; March 9, 2015)
After the trailer of Emraan
Hashmi's latest supernatural thriller, Mr. X, premiered
online, social media has been buzzing over the similarities
between the Vikram Bhatt directorial and the 2000 Hollywood thriller,
Hollow Man. There's a sequence in which Emraan's Mr. X becomes visible
when orange paint is thrown on him which seems 'inspired' by the Kevin
Bacon-starrer. However, Vikram insists that his film is “not a copy of
Hollow Man“.
“Indian filmmakers are trying to create original, quality stuff so it's sad when someone tries to bring down your film based on a two-minute teaser. Just because Krissh flies, does it make him Spiderman?“ Vikram Bhatt argues. When the specific scene was underlined to him as a reference point, he insisted that it wasn't just paint that showed up his Mr X. “He's visible through a lot of other mediums, underwater for instance,“ he said. “I don't even remember what Hollow Man is about.“
The film's producer, Mahesh Bhatt, added, “Mr X is not Hollow Man or Mr India reinvented but grew from a nostalgic yearning to revisit the Mr. X franchisee. It had Ashok Kumar playing an invisible man, was produced by GP Sippy and directed by my father Nanabhai Bhatt in 1957.“
He reasoned that just because their hero turns invisible, doesn't mean it's a rip-off. “The invisible man is not a new phenomenon,“ Bhatt said, adding that their vigilante narrative has a love story at the core and two different world views. “While his beloved believes that social and legal codes cannot be violated, he who once walked on the right side of the law, believes extraordinary situations calls for extraordinary measures.“
“Indian filmmakers are trying to create original, quality stuff so it's sad when someone tries to bring down your film based on a two-minute teaser. Just because Krissh flies, does it make him Spiderman?“ Vikram Bhatt argues. When the specific scene was underlined to him as a reference point, he insisted that it wasn't just paint that showed up his Mr X. “He's visible through a lot of other mediums, underwater for instance,“ he said. “I don't even remember what Hollow Man is about.“
The film's producer, Mahesh Bhatt, added, “Mr X is not Hollow Man or Mr India reinvented but grew from a nostalgic yearning to revisit the Mr. X franchisee. It had Ashok Kumar playing an invisible man, was produced by GP Sippy and directed by my father Nanabhai Bhatt in 1957.“
He reasoned that just because their hero turns invisible, doesn't mean it's a rip-off. “The invisible man is not a new phenomenon,“ Bhatt said, adding that their vigilante narrative has a love story at the core and two different world views. “While his beloved believes that social and legal codes cannot be violated, he who once walked on the right side of the law, believes extraordinary situations calls for extraordinary measures.“
This entry was posted on October 4, 2009 at 12:14 pm, and is filed under
Ashok Kumar,
Bollywood News,
Emraan Hashmi,
Hollow Man,
Mahesh Bhatt,
Mr X,
Vikram Bhatt
. Follow any responses to this post through RSS. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Post a Comment