Showing posts with label Phir Se. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phir Se. Show all posts

Jennifer Winget is clueless about fate of her film Phir Se

Jennifer Winget
Jennifer Winget on waiting endlessly for Phir Se's release after it was caught in a plagiarism row
Letty Mariam Abraham (MID-DAY; October 12, 2016)

Jennifer Winget is returning to television with 'Beyhadh', two years after 'Saraswatichandra' went off air. Before signing the thriller series, she had been busy with Kunal Kohli's 'Phir Se', which would have marked her solo lead debut in Bollywood. The film was supposed to hit theatres in June last year, but is now stuck after being embroiled in a copyright row.

The actress says she is unsure of the film's fate: "I did ask Kunal, but I no longer have the time to find out more about it anymore because Beyhadh takes up all my time." Daawat-E-Ishq (2014) writer Jyoti Kapoor had filed a case with Film Writers Association (FWA) in November 2014 after she found out about Kohli's film. Jyoti found his premise similar to the one she had narrated to him in January 2013. Kohli denied the allegation, but was asked to put his film's shoot on hold till the case was resolved. The FWA sent both scripts to experts for comparison and eventually, ruled in Jyoti's favour.

Jennifer says shoot and dubbing for the film have long been completed. "Now it's in the hands of god," she adds. After her divorce from Karan Singh Grover (now married to Bipasha Basu) in 2014, Jennifer says she hasn't lost faith in the institution of marriage and is ready to mingle. "I am single, ready to mingle and jingle, but how do you know I am not mingling now?" she winks.

Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis's wife Amruta sings for Jai GangaaJal


Roshmila Bhattacharya (MUMBAI MIRROR; January 25, 2016)

Amruta, the wife of the Chief Minister of Maharashtra, Devendra Fadnavis, has quietly entered Bollywood as a singer. She has already recorded two songs, for Kunal Kohli's upcoming love story, Phir Se, and Prakash Jha's soon-to-release cop drama, Jai GangaaJal. “I heard the song she had sung for Kunal Kohli and liked her voice. It's lovely, silky and very deep, I felt it was just what our devotional song, 'Sab dhan maati', required so I asked my composers, Salim-Sulaiman, to try her out. They liked her too and we recorded the track last month in two sessions over a couple of hours,“ informs Jha.

The film, which features Priyanka Chopra as the protagonist, has as many as 12 songs and all of them play in the background. This particular song is part of a sequence which features Jha himself. “I play Priyanka's junior, Deputy Superintendent of Police, BP Singh, and the song appears at a character transformation moment,“ he informs.

And what was the CM's reaction to the song? “I have no idea but Amruta was a pleasure to work with... Very simple, no airs, enthusiastic. She quietly came, recorded the song and left. The music directors later wanted to re-dub certain portions and without any fuss she came back and did the needful,“ he says warmly.

Script writer Jyoti Kapoor wins eight-month battle with Kunal Kohli for lifting her idea


Roshmila Bhattacharya (MUMBAI MIRROR; July 21, 2015)

Script-writer Jyoti Kapoor has won a case of copyright violation and breach of confidence against Bollywood director-producer Kunal Kohli of Amir Khan-starrer Fanaa fame.

The Supreme Court in a landmark verdict on Monday ruled there were similarities between the storyline of Kohli's under-production film 'Phir Se' and Jyoti's script titled 'RSVP'. The court ordered that Kohli pay Jyoti a compensation of Rs 25 lakh and give her credit for 'story idea.' The verdict brought to end an eight-month battle which took Jyoti from multiple industry dispute resolution mechanisms to the High Court and then to the Supreme Court. Her victory could well redefine the station of script writers in the industry dominated by stars and powerful production houses.

While Jyoti, who spoke to Mumbai Mirror over the phone from Karnal in Haryana, described the Supreme Court verdict as a vindication of her stand, Kohli tweeted that he was happy to bring the matter to a close and focus on releasing the film. “The judges asked us to go for a settlement and I agreed, as I don't believe in fighting with members of my fraternity. Judges felt that creative people should settle to promote creativity and culture. Case is finally over. Release date to be announced soon,“ he tweeted.

Jyoti said the verdict has brought a sense of closure after eight months of back-breaking work that at times left her disillusioned. “The compensation will take care of the lawyer's fees. This is a professional, legal and moral victory for my fraternity and me. A friend who had given up on a copyright case half-way through called to say he was reopening the case,“ Jyoti said.

She said the first thing she did after the verdict was announced was polish off the dabba a relative had packed for her in the morning. “I was ravenous. Now I've come home to my parents in Karnal and my mother has cooked a delicious dinner for me,“ she said.

Jyoti's ordeal began when her agent emailed her script to Kunal. He met her and they discussed money and credit. She wanted top billing since she had given him a bound, 90-page script. But Kunal wanted certain changes and wanted to buy the script without giving any credit to her. The deal fell through.

Jyoti then opened negotiations with another producer with whom she signed an agreement and was given an advance.

Meanwhile, Kunal started his film, which will mark his acting debut, and from what she read in the papers, Jyoti detected an uncanny resemblance with her script. Subsequently, she filed a complaint with the Film Writers Association.

The Dispute Settlement Committee of the Film Writers Association ruled in Jyoti's favour, but Kohli appealed at the Appellate Tribunal, which comprises three senior writers. The Tribunal compared the two scripts without being told who had written which one. The Tribunal too detected major overlap in the two scripts. Since Jyoti had registered her script with the Film Writers Association before Kohli began work on his film, the Tribunal declared that it was a clear case of copyright violation.

The case then moved to the Joint Dispute Settlement Committee which comprises members of the Federation of Western India Cine Employees to which all 22 trade associations are affiliated. The representatives of the producers association (IMPPA) met with those of the Federation to sort out the issue. “But just before the case came up for hearing, some calls were made seeking confidential information about who was on board prompting Jyoti to move the Bombay High Court asking for a stay on Kohli's film shoot,“ said Anjum Rajabali, activist of the Film Writers Association.

The Bombay High Court asked for a guarantee of Rs 50 lakh from Kunal but vacated the stay. That was a dark day for Jyoti who recalls breaking down in court and crying all the way home to Versova in the cab. Many friends from the industry told her to drop the case. They said she stood the risk of being blacklisted. “Bills were mounting and I wanted to be able to focus on my writing. For a moment, the thought of giving up the fight crossed my mind. But then, my husband, Harsh Warrdhan, who's also a freelance writer, and I decided to move the Supreme Court which in two hearings gave its verdict. Today, I feel vindicated for all those who've been through a similar situation and thank my family, friends, the fraternity and even strangers for their unstinting support,“ she said.

Anjum said the judgement is a shot in the arm for writers who will be encouraged to take their fight for copyright to court now. “Jyoti is not a hugely successful writer, nor does she have plenty of funds behind her,“ he said, “but she is a girl with considerable talent and spirit and has shown the fraternity the way ahead.“

Kunal has been asked to withdraw the defamation case against Jyoti. He has called her names in the media like 'extortionist' and 'publicity hungry'.

Bombay High Court rules interim stay on Kunal Kohli's film Phir Se


Hiren Kotwani (BOMBAY TIMES; May 20, 2015)

The Bombay High Court on Tuesday ruled an ad interim stay on the of Kunal Kohli's film, Phir Se. Writer Jyoti Kapoor had moved court alleging that the movie is based on her script, which she had narrated to Kohli in January 2013. Through media reports last year, Jyoti found similarities in Kohli's movie and her script and accused him of plagiarism. While he denied her claims, she went to court this February. Jyoti said, “After I went to the Film Writers Association and the Dispute Settlement Committee ruled in my favour, it wasn't easy. So I went to court. I know a lot of my writer friends have gone through this, but not everyone has the wherewithal to go to court.“

When contacted Kunal said, “What I have learnt from this experience is free exchange of ideas is no longer permissible. I'd go a step further and say that it is prohibited. Debate on copyright n plagiarism is settled, it is neither. The industry has to move towards a more close and protective environment with regards to work in progress.What is left to be decided is merely one principle aspect; what is value of an idea that should be in direct proportion to authorship?“

Jyoti Kapoor moves HC to stay release of Kunal Kohli’s film allegedly based on her script

Bharati Dubey (MID-DAY; March 21, 2015)

Writer Jyoti Kapoor has moved the Bombay High Court demanding a stay on the release of Kunal Kohli’s Phir Se, reiterating allegations that the film, slated for a May release, has been influenced by a story she once discussed with him. The case is likely to come up for hearing on March 25.

Lawyer Rahul Ajatshatru says, “Yes, Jyoti Kapoor has filed a case against Kunal Kohli and others asking for restraining release of the film Phir Se.” The Daawat-E-Ishq co-writer had, in November last year, accused Kohli of plagiarism.

Through media reports on the film, Jyoti found the plotline was eerily similar to a story she had narrated to Kohli in January 2013. He, however, denied the allegations but was asked to put his film’s shoot on hold till the case was resolved. The FWA, which sent both scripts to experts for comparison, ruled in Jyoti’s favour.

Producer Trilok Malhotra, who is currently making a film on Jyoti’s script, had also had filed a complaint with Indian Motion Picture Producers Association. After this, a dispute settlement committee was called by the Federation of Western Indian Cine Employees wherein Malhotra and Kohli were called to resolve the issue.

Despite repeated attempts, Kohli did not revert to our text messages or e-mails.

M S Dhoni biopic director Neeraj Pandey to dedicate a song 'Phir Se' to Team India on Feb 15


Priya Gupta (BOMBAY TIMES; February 12, 2015)

As we all know, the ICC Cricket World Cup 2015 is being held in Australia and New Zealand with India playing its first match against archrival Pakistan on February 15. The Indian team will predictably have the World Cup 2011 winning captain MS Dhoni leading the team. We have exclusively learnt that the director of M S Dhoni's biopic, Neeraj Pandey, a cricket buff himself, has directed a music video titled Phir Se that will be launched on February 15, the day of the India-Pakistan match. Telling us about it, he said, “Phir Se is an anthem, plea, prayer, dream all rolled in one. M M Kreem sahab (music director) and Manoj Muntashir (lyricist) have done this beautifully.“ Well, there is no doubt that a billion hearts will be with Dhoni, praying and hoping that he will bring back the World Cup phir se to India.

Sumona Chakravarti gives cold shoulder to Jennifer Winget on Phir Se sets?


Sumona Chakravarti and Jennifer Winget
Sonali Joshi Pitale (MID-DAY; January 30, 2015)

If sources are to be believed, television starlet Sumona Chakravarti would soon be seen on the big screen. She is apparently playing a key role in Kunal Kohli’s Phir Se that has another telly actress Jennifer Winget in the lead. But the fact that the makers have, so far, chosen to promote only Jennifer apparently hasn’t gone down well with Sumona.

A source says, “She has an important role in the film which has not been publicised at all. So far, only Kunal, who is making his acting debut, and Jennifer have spoken about the film and have featured on the posters. This has upset Sumona.” It is said that the actress has not only asked the makers to give her more visibility in the film, but is also looking through her fellow actress on the sets.

Sumona, however, denies the buzz saying: “I am happy with my role as it has turned out exactly the way it was narrated to me. Jennifer and I are also getting along well.”

Kunal says Sumona would be involved in the promotions at a later stage. “We have just started the promotions. When the time is right, we will promote her,” he adds.

Sumona was also seen in Barfi! (2012) and Kick (2014).

Film Writer's Association deems Kunal Kohli a plagiarist

FWA deems Kunal a plagiarist
The Association found stark similarities between his and Jyoti Kapoor's script
Ankur Pathak (MUMBAI MIRROR; November 27, 2014)

On Tuesday evening, the Dispute Settlement Committee of the Film Writer's Association passed a decision in favour of Jyoti Kapoor in the plagiarism case she had filed against filmmaker Kunal Kohli.

An expert panel from the FWA went through both the scripts and observed that "some of the situations and sequences are quite unique to merit attention. Taking into account the fact that the respondent (Kunal Kohli) had access to the complainant's script, these points of similarities suggest that the respondent's work was definitely influenced by the complainant's work."

Jyoti had accused Kunal of stealing her script. She had claimed that Kunal met her in January last year and expressed interest in buying a script of hers. Since the duo couldn't agree on credit-sharing and the renumeration, Jyoti, who has previously written Daawat-e-Ishq, took her script to another production house.

She was in for a rude shock when she learnt that Kunal is directing a film, based on the same premise as the script she had shared with him. She filed a case against him with the FWA on October 10 this year, while Kunal maintained that his was an original script written by him and Sukhmini Sadana.

Hours after the FWA verdict, Mirror spoke to Jyoti, who said, "For me, this means truth and justice has prevailed."

However, Kunal reacted sharply to this. Speaking from London, where he has already started shooting the film based on the contested script, he said, "The FWA's decision is based on 3 points that are non-existent in my script. I've appealed against that."

Jyoti maintains that she did not file the case for a monetary settlement. "Kunal needs to stop this film and move on to another script. Since my script has already been acquired by another production house, I am not looking for money. This fight was for one's rights as a writer to pitch one's work without the fear of the idea being stolen."

To which Kunal shot back, saying, "She's lying that she doesn't want money. I have a letter from her lawyer asking for a monetary settlement." 

--------------------------
Film writers celebrate Jyoti Kapoor’s victory, but rue lack of respect for original ideas
Bharati Dubey (MID-DAY; November 27, 2014)

The Bollywood writers’ fraternity has hailed the judgment of the Film Writers Association (FWA) upholding Jyoti Kapoor’s plagiarism allegations against filmmaker Kunal Kohli.

The association has stated that Kohli’s upcoming project, Phir Se, has been influenced by the Daawat-E-Ishq writer’s story that she had sent to him much before he completed his script. Jyoti had filed the complaint against Kohli earlier this month.

Vinod Rangnath, chairman of Dispute Settlement Committee of FWA, confirms Jyoti’s victory while the visibly excited writer tells hitlist, “I am glad that we are talking about things like copyright protection and ethics which were almost non-existent in the industry until recently. I look at the FWA judgment as a landmark decision and a moral victory, not only for me but also fellow writers who have faced a similar situation. Until we stand up for our own rights, no one else will.”

Following the verdict, the Federation of Western India Cine Employees (FWICE) has written to the filmmaker asking him to stop work on his project until their meeting with the joint dispute settlement committee of Indian Motion Picture Producers Association about the case takes place on December 10.

Dilip Pithwa, general secretary of FWICE, says: “We have already notified Kunal Kohli about the FWA verdict which has ruled in Jyoti Kapoor’s favour. If he continues shooting for the film, we will launch a non- cooperation movement against him.”

Copyright society needed
While the writers’ community has welcomed Jyoti’s victory, it feels there still are other issues that need to be ironed out. Writer Sanjay Chauhan, who has penned the script for films like I am Kalam and Maine Gandhi Ko Nahin Maara, says the concept of a ‘film industry’ was a misnomer. “Had that been the case, writers would have been paid for research and development for a project, like it happens in the West. I am glad that more writers have started fighting for their rights and the FWA and the Indian Copyright (Amendment) Act have given them the courage to speak out. Of course, there are a few producers like Ritesh Sidhwani who understand the rights of a writer and will encourage you to register your script before sending it to their office,” he states.

Scriptwriters believe that though awareness about their rights is gradually growing, original ideas aren’t worth much. Anand Sivakumaran, who has written for films like Kalyug and Nazar, states, “At the international stage, for every character you create, you have a copyright on it and make money for a lifetime.Here, we can keep fighting individual battles but fundamentally nothing will change unless a copyright society is formed and the amended Act is implemented. In our industry, only money is respected so the one who gets paid Rs 50 crore is held in high regard, not people with original ideas.”

No room for originality?
Though the film industry has been stressing on the fact that content is the king, the ground reality is dramatically different, argues writer-director Amit Masurkar. He says, “The producers don’t respect writers as they are ruled by ‘ stars’. Hearing industry people say that there no good writers in Bollywood makes me laugh as it is all rubbish. We are there and have gone to them with our script but they didn’t bother reading it. They don’t mind buying the rights of a foreign film for Rs 50 lakh but will not pay a writer with an original idea.”

Amit is full of praise for Jyoti for pursuing the case against Kohli. He says plagiarism cases are commonplace in Bollywood. Without divulging the names of those who stole his ideas, he recalls, “I am someone who discusses ideas openly and one of my friends used it to his advantage. A day before his film was to release, he called me up to inform that he has stolen a sequence from my script and asked me not to create a ruckus! On another occasion, a director working with a famed studio lifted the first half of my script and sent it to a star. Luckily, the actor informed me about the same. The film eventually was not made, so I did not knock on FWA’s doors.”

Case file
Writer Jyoti Kapoor filed a case with Film Writers Association (FWA) earlier this month after she came across media reports about Kunal Kohli’s film, Phir Se.

Jyoti found his premise similar to the one she had narrated to him in January 2013. Kunal Kohli denied the allegations but was asked to put his film’s shoot on hold till the case was resolved. The FWA sent both scripts to experts for comparsion and uncanny similarities were found. Producer Trilok Malhotra is now making a film on Jyoti’s script.

Kunal Kohli asked to suspend shoot of Phir Se due to plagiarism charges?

The poster of Kunal Kohli’s Phir Se. The writer-director has turned actor for the film which will see him romancing TV actress, Jennifer Winget
Bharati Dubey (MID-DAY; November 10, 2014)

Daawat-E-Ishq co-writer, Jyoti Kapoor, who has accused Kohli of stealing her scriptDaawat-E- Ishq co-writer, Jyoti Kapoor has filed a complaint with the Film Writers Association ( FWA) alleging director Kunal Kohli’s next film, Phir Se, is based on the story she had narrated to him last year. The case is now pending before the FWA’s dispute settlement committee with Kohli denying the accusations.

An industry source says, “Kapoor’s agency had sent her script to Kunal Kohli early last year. He liked it a lot and when he met her, he suggested certain changes in the script. There were also some issues regarding credit and money. Eventually, the deal did not materialise.” Kapoor is then said to have taken the script to veteran production executive, Trilok Malhotra to make the film.

However, when Kohli announced about his film, she felt that it bore uncanny resemblance to her story. The source adds, “Her agency had e-mailed the script to Kohli. His quotes about his film that have been flashed in the media also indicate that it is Kapoor’s story.

Defending himself, Kohli labels the allegations as a “case of harassment” and questions Kapoor’s claims. “How does she know which film I am making? This is being done just to extort money and so that one can be written about and get their two minutes of fame. Fraud cases like this discourage producer-directors from meeting new talent as you can never predict the intentions of people you meet,” he rues.

Kapoor refuses to divulge details of the case but says, “Neither my producer nor I want any money from Kohli. We just want him to stop making his film. As far as my two minutes of fame is concerned, Mr Kohli should check his facts. I am a graduate of the Film and Television Institute of India and a former journalist.
I have really worked hard to reach where I am in this industry.”

Malhotra, who is making a film with Kapoor’s story, has also filed a case with the Indian Motion Picture Producers Association (IMPPA). Association president, T P Aggarwal confirms the news, saying: “Our member Trilok Malhotra came to us along with the writer with the complaint that he has the rights to the story and Kohli cannot make it. He has already paid the money to the writer. We have written to Kunal Kohli to attend the dispute meeting and he cannot start shooting for the film till issue is resolved.”

Meanwhile, the Federation of Western India Cine Employees (FWICE) has sent a letter to Kohli preventing him from starting the shoot for his film. General secretary of FWICE, Dilip Pithwa says, “The case is currently under dispute. Kohli was called for the dispute settlement committee meeting which he did not attend. So we have sent him a letter asking him not to start shooting for his film till the case is resolved. If he does not comply to our directions, we will be forced to launch a non- cooperation movement against him.”

Both Kohli and president of Film and Television Producer Guild, Mukesh Bhatt denied having received any such letter from the FWICE. Bhatt states, “I have not received any such intimation from the FWICE and I am not saying this to protect my member. Let the FWA compare the two scripts and give its verdict. But nobody has the right to stop anybody’s work.”

Kunal Kohli to romance Jennifer Winget in Phir Se?

Hero Kunal finds his heroine
Ankur Pathak (MUMBAI MIRROR; October 3, 2014)

Mirror (September 15) was the first to report that director Kunal Kohli will turn actor with Phir Se, a film set in London, which he will also helm. Now we have learnt that the Hum Tum director has found his leading lady.

Jennifer Winget, known for popular TV shows like Dil Mill Gayye and Kya Hoga Nimmo Ka and more recently Saraswatichandra, will be seen opposite Kunal in the film, a romantic drama expected to go on floors this November.

A photo-shoot was recently done at Bandra's Mehboob Studio to finalise the look of the duo.

Revealed a source close to the production, "Jennifer plays an independent, headstrong girl who moves from Amritsar to London to start her life from scratch after an ugly divorce. In London, she meets Kunal's character, also a divorcee."

According to the source, the film deals with the complexities of a new romance and a second attempt at a happily ever after.

Kunal Kohli remained unavailable for comment.