Richa Pinto (THE TIMES OF INDIA; February 15, 2015)

Residents say Poonam Mahajan’s letter to the Municipal Commissioner will give them an important leg up in the fight against the ramp outside Mannat; they said they hope it will be demolished given the MP’s support and the change in government
Varun Singh (MID-DAY; February 3, 2015)


People power may well trump star power in this battle. Bandra residents’ fight to reclaim a stretch of road which has allegedly been encroached upon by a ramp constructed by actor Shah Rukh Khan has got an important leg up in the form of support from local MP Poonam Mahajan, who has written a letter to the BMC on the issue.

According to local residents, this is the first time that a member of parliament who represents Bandra (which is a part of the Mumbai North Central parliamentary constituency) has written a letter about the cement ramp next to Mannat, which is often used by Khan to park his vanity van.

Mahajan wrote to Municipal Commissioner Sitaram Kunte on January 29 and asked him to get the illegal cement ramp demolished. She, however, mentioned an illegal ramp constructed by a bungalow owner in Bandra and refrained from taking the names of Khan or Mannat.

Residents say the ramp prevents them from using a thoroughfare and blocks the way to the stairs that lead to Mount Mary Church from Bandstand. It becomes especially important during the Bandra fair, which is held every year in the month of September.

Hope bolstered
They say that they have been running from pillar to post to get the ramp removed, but to no avail and they are hoping that things change with Mahajan getting involved.

Advocate Shane Cardoz, a resident who has been fighting against the ramp, said, “A few residents had met Poonam regarding the matter, and she wrote a letter to the BMC. With her involvement in the case, we are expecting that things will move faster. The change in the government has also bolstered our hopes. The ramp becomes an issue, especially when people are stopped from using the road. It is a public road, why should people be stopped from using it?” He added, “In the last few months, we could get many slums demolished because the political interference is decreasing. Things are changing and the people of Bandra want to use the road as it belongs to the government.”

‘People above all’
When mid-day spoke to Mahajan, she said she wrote the letter after the residents met her and showed her documents that proved that the road belongs to the government and should be handed over to the public for use. “The roads in Bandra are narrow as it is, and no individual or organisation is above the people.

The road belongs to the government and should be promised the residents that I would try to resolve whatever problem they have. Justice should be done irrespective of who the person on the other side is.” Mahajan said that she didn’t take any names in the letter because she didn’t feel like dragging in any individual. “I have written to the commissioner and will follow up with him. My only issue is that the road, which is meant for the people, should be used by them. During the Bandra fair, the path is used a lot and the ramp leads to chaos. The issue needs to be sorted out,” she said.

Prakkash G Rohiira, a realtor who uses the road often, said, “This is not the first time that public property has been modified for personal convenience but, knowing Shah Rukh, we feel he will understand the people’s troubles and sort this issue out.”

A source close to Shah Rukh Khan said that the road belongs to the actor and has not been taken over by the BMC yet. “We are ready to give the road, but the BMC hasn’t yet taken it. Until the BMC takes it over, it is our property.” Neither Khan nor Municipal Commissioner Sitaram Kunte responded to our calls and messages.

Court case
In September, activist Nicholas Almeida had moved a local court in Bandra seeking to file a nuisance lawsuit against Shah Rukh Khan for “illegally” constructing the ramp adjoining his residence. Municipal Commissioner Sitaram Kunte and three of his subordinates had also been made respondents.

“The said illegal ramp constructed by Khan is an important thoroughfare, especially during the Bandra fair, which is being held every year in the month of September since the last three centuries,” the complainant had said in his plea.

Asira Tarannum (MID-DAY; August 20, 2014)

The Watchdog Foundation has sent a fresh complaint to municipal commissioner Sitaram Kunte regarding no public access to a road next to Shah Rukh Khan’s bungalow, Mannat. The road next to King Khan’s bungalow is a shorter route to Mount Mary Church, but it has been closed since the last three years.

It may be pointed out that SRK’s bungalow is located near to the Mount Mary Church where thousands of pilgrims flock during the annual Bandra fair. The road located between SRK’s home and the church has apparently been blocked for SRK’s safety and this is said to have caused a nuisance to pilgrims. Last year after some agitation, the road was opened on the third day of the annual Bandra fair, but soon after, it was closed again.

Nicholas Almeida, trustee of the Watchdog Foundation says, “We have recently written to the CM and the BMC commissioner. The commissioner has asked for a fresh inquiry and a report will be submitted to him. With the road being closed, a lot of people face problems as it is a short cut. Also, it is illegal to just stop people from taking that route. The road was opened to the public last year and at that time, we were assured that it will be open permanently. But yet again, it has been closed.”

He adds that SRK’s security has been stopping people from taking that road. “Security guards deployed at Mannat don’t allow people to take the short cut to the church. His vanity van is also parked on the ramp,” he says.

When contacted, Prashant Satpale, Assistant Deputy Commissioner, BMC Zone 3, confirmed that the commissioner has asked him to conduct an inquiry to look into the matter. “ I have been asked to do an inquiry and send him the report,” he said.

Meanwhile, a source close to the actor says, “SRK’s vanity van is parked on a property which belongs to Mannat and it is never parked on the road. The actor has nothing to do with it. In fact, the ramp was created earlier on, even before SRK purchased the bungalow.”

Another source says, “It was the decision of the cops to close the road next to Mannat, as the road is quite narrow and they wished to avoid calamities during the Bandra Fair.”