Delhi Crime, based on the investigations that went into the brutal gang rape of Nirbhaya on December 16, 2012, leading to her subsequent death, won the best drama series at the 48th International Emmy Awards, last month.

Ever since the series has been released, Chhaya Sharma – former DCP South Delhi, who led the special investigation team that cracked the case and on whom the character of Shefali Shah’s Vartika Chaturvedi is based —has been getting calls from curious people from across the world, who have many questions for the police officer. One caller even wanted to know “if she’s for real”, while another wanted to hear just how she sounds. Yesterday — the eighth anniversary of the Nirbhaya incident — Sharma, currently posted as Director, Central Vigilance Commission in Delhi, spoke to us about the show, Delhi Crime and more.

Chhaya Sharma was not very keen on meeting (the writer-director Richie Mehta) for the show, but it was her former boss, former Delhi Police Commissioner Neeraj Kumar, who convinced her.

She says, “I was initially not very keen. When I spoke to Richie for the first time, he was quite excited about the project and was ready to come to Mizoram (where she was posted then). But I told him that we’ll meet in Delhi when I’m there. Incidentally, the next time when I went to Delhi, he was there and when I met him, I found that he meant business, and he was quite serious about the project.”

Sharma says that she wasn’t initially convinced “that many would believe that it’s a positive police story of how the police detected and investigated a sensational case. However, Richie was open and was willing to tell the story from a different perspective.”

She adds, “Most of the people working on films or documentaries about the police system aren’t aware how police departments actually work and that’s why I used to tell Richie that he should go to police stations, just sit and observe how things work. I think he went to all the spots and police stations. In fact, he even went to meet doctors and visited the hospital.”

Sharma had seen the unedited versions of Delhi Crime. She says, “Stories on police officials should be shown as how they are in real life, which is almost never the case in films. We are not ‘Simmba’ or ‘Singham’. We are not larger than life. We are not super humans. We are normal human beings, we don’t have antennas. Whatever detective skills we have, we acquire it (while working). And with due credit to Richie, he has shown the investigation right. I was also very happy that he chose Shefali for the role because she is an actor whose work I have followed,” adding, “Richie told me, ‘I chose Shefali because your eyes are similar’ (laughs).”

Not just Richie and Shefali, who sought her inputs, the costume team members of the show also used to send her photos of the police uniforms to check if they got them right. She says, “I told them that it’s the police uniform, be careful. It is very irritating to see a sub-inspector in a DIG’s uniform and a DIG in a sub-inspector’s uniform.”

Richie had interviewed every member of the Special Investigation Team, from the former Delhi Police Commissioner Neeraj Kumar, who was also a consultant for Delhi Crime, to the sub-inspectors and constables. Sharma says, “He took my version, my ACP’s version, my inspector and sub-inspectors’ versions, and then he came with the first draft. He asked me if I wanted to have a look at it, but I was busy with my work. So I broadly told him that you have got all the versions, now tell the story as it is. I told him that this is a positive story and it should be told as such.”

Shar ma adds, “I was answerable to the victim’s family and the court. I’m not interested whether the story is told or not, but I didn’t want it to be something that it is not. Whatever is presented in a series or a movie creates a perception in the minds of the public. And it is very difficult to tell them, ‘see, it is not like that’.”

Sharma is happy with the way the show has been made. She says, “I was happy to note the way in which our efforts and hard work were highlighted in the series. A lot of respect was shown in the scenes related to the victim. The challenges and travails of some of our smaller teams in the fields were well captured. Some character amalgamations were done for cinematic purposes, but the efforts put in the telling the story – in its nearly original form, yet keeping all sensitivity on track – was amazing. It was a job done well.”

Talking about the characters, Sharma says, “Denzil Smith (who played Shefali’s husband in the show) never met my husband, but he played his role superbly because Richie had done his research well. Adil Hussain was superb in displaying the suave and competent Delhi CP Neeraj Kumar. Rajesh Tailang and Jaya Bhattacharya did equal justice to their characters. Most actors who spoke to me had based their work on Richie’s research and that’s why we can see an equation between characters in the series.” Richie did a careful study of the case and characters for over five years, Sharma adds.

FINDING LOVE
As the gates opened, you were transported into a private little dreamworld, a sanctuary, where you were confronted by a split-level home of stone and glass built on a hill, surrounded by greenery.

This was the residence of Mukesh Agarwal. Born into a middle-class Bania family, Mukesh had abandoned studying at the age of 13. For many years he did odd jobs. Then, in the late 1970s, at the age of 24, he started a company of his own that manufactured kitchenware under the brand name Hotline. Sifting through the pages of Mukesh's past, I came upon Neeraj Kumar, Mukesh's one-time friend. A retired Indian Police Service officer, Neeraj Kumar had served as Delhi's commissioner of police. Mukesh's and Neeraj Kumar's paths had crossed at the time that Hotline made ripples in Delhi due to its success. According to Neeraj Kumar, 'Mukesh Agarwal belonged to that breed of entrepreneurs who made it big at a time when others had not emerged. All these start-up scenarios had not happened.' From an ordinary background, Mukesh had always wanted to break into the circles of Delhi's elite. Craving for social prominence, he threw lavish parties for Delhi's socialites. He made it a point to invite every film celebrity who happened to be in town. Neeraj Kumar remembers Mukesh as a 'very nice guy, very kind, but he had a complex. The complex was that he wanted to show that he has arrived. He did not believe in keeping a low profile.' Mukesh was known for his eccentricities; he'd do practically anything to catch a celebrity's eye.

There was a time in Delhi when the glamorous Rekha and the famous fashion designer and socialite Bina Ramani would catch up with each other often. Over one such meeting, Rekha expressed a desire to get married and to settle down. All she sought then was a man who could be her partner for life. It was early 1990. One evening, Rekha's phone rang. It was Bina Ramani from Delhi. She wanted Rekha to talk to her 'crazy fan'. Bina told Rekha that this crazy fan of hers was a well-known businessman from Delhi, and also a very good human being. 'His name is Mukesh Agarwal. Shall I give him your number?' Rekha told her not to. Instead, she took his number.

The first conversation between them was formal but it is said that Mukesh was completely enamoured by Rekha's husky voice. He was also over the moon that a woman worshipped by millions in India had rung him up. Rekha had taken the first step. A series of phone calls between the two then followed. Rekha's Delhi-based friend Surinder Kaur was witness to this relationship since its beginning. Surinder was an air hostess and was very close to Rekha at that time. She wanted to see Rekha settled down. Bina and Surinder repeatedly coaxed Rekha: 'He is a great guy...don't let this chance go by.' Rekha and Mukesh met for the first time in Bombay within a month of their first phone call. For Rekha, tired of the pretenses and demands of showbiz, Mukesh was a pleasant change. His simple and honest demeanour signalled a rare genuineness to her. Clearly star-struck, Mukesh paid her dazzling compliments, something that Rekha had always loved. He left no stone unturned in wooing her, and lavished her with affection. As with everything else in his life, Mukesh went overboard.

He persuaded Rekha to visit Delhi, and she did. Soon, she stood at the centre of attention in his sprawling farmhouse in Chhatarpur, Basera. This was a welcome change from the glitz of Bombay. One could easily get used to the fawning respect, adulation and attention she got. A bond grew between the two of them: he loved her queen-diva image and she loved his till-death-do-us-part devotion.

Sunday, 4 March 1990. It had been just over a month since Rekha and Mukesh had first met. He was restless. Noon found him sitting in Rekha's house along with Surinder Kaur. Without preamble, he proposed marriage. 'Surinder goaded me into saying yes to Mukesh when he came over to Bombay again,' Rekha said recalling that day. Mukesh couldn't control his excitement. Jumping up with joy he said, 'Let's get married right away!' Neither of their families were in Bombay; still, they decided that the wedding had to take place that very day. It was as if they were scared that if not then, it might not happen at all. Rekha was finally getting married. After a lifetime of seeking, Rekha, born out of wedlock, had finally got what she most desired: a legitimate surname.

The initial days in London were beautiful. That was the first time that Rekha and Mukesh had spent so much time together. But it took only a week for Rekha to realise that they were very different people. She was also shocked to see Mukesh taking several pills a day. Still, she thought, now that they had to spend the rest of their lives together, such matters would have to be overlooked. 'I've to make [a] success of it,' she told herself. 'Can Rekha fail in anything she attempts?' They had been in London for more than a week. Rekha could see that something was troubling Mukesh. And then, one day, a gloomy Mukesh looked deep into her eyes and said, 'There's an AB in my life too.'

BREAKING BAD
While everybody knew who Rekha's AB was, the AB in Mukesh Agarwal's life was Akash Bajaj. She was his psychotherapist and had been treating him for the last ten years. She had also been involved with him personally. Neeraj Kumar remembered, 'Mukesh was a chronic patient of depression and, if I'm not wrong, it ran in his family.' Mukesh's sister and a few other members of his family had suffered from depression, making him genetically predisposed to the condition. His was a severe case, and it was Akash who was responsible for him getting better. Neeraj Kumar remarked, 'She had kind of nursed him back from [the] absolute brink of despair.' Back in Bombay, Rekha and Mukesh threw a small party for close friends to celebrate their wedding. Mukesh was then going through a phase of depression. According to Neeraj Kumar, 'I clearly remember it was Santa Cruz Centaur Hotel. Mukesh was on [the] phone line with me, saying that “Neeraj, I'm going to jump off!“' Mukesh's depression had been manifesting in strong suicidal tendencies. Neeraj Kumar tried to talk him out of it, and reminded him of his recent wedding. 'He felt there was no meaning to his life and he wanted to end it. This had been a regular occurrence with Mukesh and was getting tiresome for people close to him,' remembered Neeraj Kumar.

Meanwhile, Rekha had been giving interviews in which she proclaimed Mukesh as the love of her life. 'My first reaction to his name - Mukesh Agarwal - it didn't have that ring of romance to it. It was so far removed from what I had ever dreamt of. But today Mukesh Agarwal is the name for me,' Rekha said.

The glow of the relationship held for a few more months, till the reality of life caught up with the couple. On her weekend visits to Delhi, Rekha would often find that Mukesh had plans to party. Though desperate to spend some alone time with her husband, she found herself mostly surrounded by loud crowds. These incidents made her feel like she was probably nothing more than a trophy wife for Mukesh, who constantly wanted to show her off to the world. The two, of course, were the talk of the town, and Mukesh left no opportunity to flaunt Rekha, have her by his side.

The year they got married, 1990, saw a worldwide financial crisis and Mukesh too suffered setbacks in his business, though he kept Rekha in the dark about them. When she found out, disillusionment set in. Cracks were beginning to appear in their marriage. Mukesh was a man of extremes, and Rekha was only just beginning to realise this. A mere two months after their wedding, Rekha's visits to Delhi started becoming infrequent. Mukesh couldn't bear her long absences and even wanted her to stop working in films, a demand that was not just irrational but violated their agreement at the time of the wedding. 'I'll quit only when I'm pregnant,' Rekha had told Mukesh.

The Mukesh who had appeared mature and sincere at the beginning of their association now behaved like a teenaged fan. When Rekha cut down on her visits to Delhi, Mukesh began spending more time in Bombay. Rather than paying attention to his failing business, he idled away time on Rekha's shoots and at Bollywood parties. Acquaintances would often ask Rekha in disbelief: was this the guy she had married? Mukesh's behaviour was becoming a source of embarrassment for Rekha, but he didn't realise it. Obsessed with the glitz of tinseltown, he just couldn't help himself.

Three months into the marriage, the magnitude of her folly dawned on Rekha. She took a step back from the all-consuming relationship, and bought some time to think things through. But when making sense of the situation proved to be too difficult, she started distancing herself from Mukesh and his family. She stopped taking his phone calls. For a depressed Mukesh, this came as a huge blow. Reports of chinks in their relationship found their way into various publications, with headlines like 'Rekha Exposed' and 'The Shocking Past of Rekha's Husband'. The impact of his actions, however, was the exact opposite of what he had hoped: Rekha receded into her shell and pushed him further away. Divorce papers were being prepared in Bombay. Mukesh was desperate, frustrated and chronically depressed. On 10 September 1990, when Mukesh called Rekha she took his call. They talked and agreed to get divorced by mutual consent, just six months into their marriage. On 26 September, Rekha left for America to be part of a stage show.

THE WITCH HUNT
On 2 October 1990, nearly seven months after his marriage to Rekha, Mukesh seemed rather happy. 'He woke up early in the morning and came to lie down in my room. We had breakfast together. He even told my wife to prepare some lunch as he'd be coming home at about 1.30 pm,' Mukesh's brother Anil Gupta recalled. He left home to meet his close friend Akash Bajaj. Then he went to his farmhouse, Basera. Smiling, he told his cook that he was famished and asked for his favourite dishes to be made. 'I am going to sleep in my room. Do not wake me up till the food is ready,' Mukesh reportedly said and retired to his room. He picked up Rekha's dupatta and fashioned a noose out of it. Climbing on top of his bed, he tied one end of the dupatta to the ceiling fan, pulled the noose around his neck and hanged himself.

Earlier, in 1986, the fantasy film Nagina, where Sridevi played an ichchhadhari nagin, shape-shifting snake, proved to be a mammoth blockbuster, catapulting her to superstardom. With Sheshnaag (1990), Rekha also jumped on to the nagin bandwagon. A little after its release, Mukesh's death made headlines. People started to blacken Rekha's face on Sheshnaag posters. At some places, they even threw dung at it. And so started a national witch hunt.

The press lapped up the sensational story of Mukesh's suicide and featured reports with outrageous headlines like 'The Black Widow' (Showtime, November 1990) and 'The Macabre Truth behind Mukesh's Suicide' (Cine Blitz, November 1990). An angry Anil Gupta said, 'My brother loved Rekha truly. For him love was a do or die attempt. He could not tolerate what Rekha was doing to him. Now what does she want, does she want our money?'Akash Bajaj, too, remarked, 'I am angry at his death and absolutely furious with the person who caused this to him. I want to lash out and ask why?' The reaction of the film fraternity was vociferous: 'Rekha has put such a blot on the face of the film industry that it'll be difficult to wash it away easily. I think after this any respectable family will think twice before accepting any actress as their bahoo,' said Subhash Ghai. 'It's going to be tough even professionally for her. No conscientious director will work with her ever again. How will the audience accept her as Bharat ki nari or insaf ki devi?' Subhash Ghai added. 'She's become the national vamp. Professionally and personally, I think it's curtains for her. I mean I don't know how will I react to her if I come face to face with her,' said Anupam Kher, her co-star in several films of that time.

The national obsession with Rekha's love life had overnight morphed into a national hatred of her. She was branded a witch, a heartless man-eater who did not think twice before killing her husband. There was no future for her, it was deemed. She had no major films in hand, and the industry was unanimous that it didn't want her back. Rekha was projected as a symbol of everything that was wrong and unacceptable in Indian society.

Rekha: The Untold Story by Yasser Usman has been published by Juggernaut. The Juggernaut app is available on the Android and iOS.